xxxxPreference Representation and the Influence of Political Parties in Majoritarian vs. Proportional Systems: An Almost Ideal Empirical Test
نویسندگان
چکیده
Electoral systems determine the role party affiliations play in political representation. According to conventional expectations, politicians’ party affiliations should influence political representation when they are elected by proportional representation. In contrast, majoritarian systems force politicians to converge to the median position of their constituents, and party affiliation should play no or at least a much smaller role. We test these predictions with unique quasi-experimental data within a common party system by matching referenda decisions of constituents with voting behavior of their representatives, who are elected either by a majoritarian system or proportional representation.
منابع مشابه
In a comprehensive and systematic examination of democratic legislatures, Taagepera and Shugart (1989) develop a "generalized Duverger's Rule." In an exhaustive empirical analysis they find a positive relationship between district magnitude and the size
Falling into a Niche: Institutional Equilibrium between Plurality and Proportional Representation for Large Political Parties" Scholars of electoral systems (e.g., Duverger, 1954; Rae 1967) argue that a combination of electoral system and district magnitude provide the strategic incentives for political party competition. All electoral systems reward large parties with a disproportional seat bo...
متن کاملA comparative spatial analysis of majoritarian and proportional elections
This study estimates spatial representations of recent elections in Canada, France, The Netherlands and Israel. Its purpose is to test whether there exist systematic differences in the extent of spatial dispersion among parties and candidates in the majoritarian and proportional electoral systems. Canada and France are majoritarian systems, while The Netherlands and Israel are highly proportion...
متن کاملThe Electoral Sweet Spot: Low-Magnitude Proportional Electoral Systems
Can electoral rules be designed to achieve political ideals such as accurate representation of voter preferences and accountable governments? The academic literature commonly divides electoral systems into two types, majoritarian and proportional, and implies a straightforward trade-off by which having more of an ideal that a majoritarian system provides means giving up an equal measure of what...
متن کاملComparing Political Executives Recruited by Proportional and Majoritarian Rules of Election Evidence from Swiss Communities
Hans Geser Zürich, July 2012 Abstract On the basis of survey data including about 50% of all members of Swiss municipal executives, it is found that election rules (proportional vs. majoritarian) have manifold impacts on the communal party systems and executive recruitment processes as well as the behavioral dispositions of the incumbents, the activities of the board as well as its position in ...
متن کاملGemeinde und Verwaltung Comparing Political Executives Recruited by Proportional and Majoritarian Rules of Election Evidence from Swiss Communities
Hans Geser Zürich, July 2012 Abstract On the basis of survey data including about 50% of all members of Swiss municipal executives, it is found that election rules (proportional vs. majoritarian) have manifold impacts on the communal party systems and executive recruitment processes as well as the behavioral dispositions of the incumbents, the activities of the board as well as its position in ...
متن کامل